Where Indiana gathers since 1996
Benjamin's has called a beautifully restored Victorian home on Philadelphia Street its home since 1996 — a place built to feed people well and bring a community together.
Benjamin's | Our Story
Born in a Victorian House
In 1996, Ben and Peggy Bruns saw something special in a stately Victorian house on Philadelphia Street — seven intimate dining rooms and a place worthy of a special occasion. By 1997, it had been lovingly renovated into Indiana's year-round dining destination.
How the Space Grew
In 2007, a major expansion added a new kitchen, an indoor-outdoor bar, and Jamin's — a brick courtyard with a fire pit, bocce court, and gazebo stage unlike anything Indiana had seen before. A 2011 pavilion with removable walls stretched the season even further.
Mary Anne's 24-Year Dream
Years before she ever owned it, Mary Anne Spadafora stood in that very Victorian living room and told a friend it would make a great restaurant someday. In 2019, she stepped in with her four daughters to honor what Ben and Peggy built — and add her own personal touch.
Indiana's Own Place
In a college town where truly special dining is rare, Benjamin's has become the place locals claim as their own — for date nights, rehearsal dinners, and long summer evenings on the patio. We invite you to come taste it for yourself.
A Note from the Owner:
A long time ago, I was at an auction standing in the living room of this beautiful old Victorian home and saying to my friend how this would make a great restaurant someday. Who would have thought that 24 years later Peg and Ben Bruns would make my dream come true! It has always been my passion to give people a great place to enjoy delicious food. Peg and Ben built this gem and have given me a wonderful endeavor. I am thankful and blessed and making improvements for you to enjoy. I have four wonderful daughters who help out at the restaurant in any way they can. Please come and taste our delicious food and cocktails and enjoy the beautiful atmosphere here at Benjamin’s!
Mary Anne Spadafora
Owner