Skip to main
Benjamin's
  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Starters
  • Salads
  • Pizzas
  • Grilled Flatbreads
  • Hand Helds/Wraps/Paninis
  • Burgers
  • Tacos
  • Mac N' Cheese
  • Pastas
  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Seafood

Benjamin's Menu

458 Philadelphia St, Indiana, PA

458 Philadelphia St, Indiana, PA

·

  • PopularCurrent Category
  • Starters
  • Salads
  • Pizzas
  • Grilled Flatbreads
  • Hand Helds/Wraps/Paninis
  • Burgers
  • Tacos
  • Mac N' Cheese
  • Pastas
  • Beef
  • Chicken
  • Seafood

Popular

  • Pierogies.

    Pierogies

    $14.42

  • Ben's Bangin' Shrimp.

    Ben's Bangin' Shrimp

    $16.48

  • Pittsburgh Salad-Chicken.

    Pittsburgh Salad-Chicken

    $17.51

  • Greek Salad.

    Greek Salad

    $17.51

Starters

Ben's Bangin' Shrimp

$16.48

Tempura fried shrimp with a Thai chili glaze over asian slaw

Ben's Bangin' Shrimp.

Fried Brie

$15.45

Beer-battered brie, golden fried and served with melba sauce

Fried Brie.

Asiago Peppers

$16.48

Banana peppers halved, stuffed with a blend of spicy & mild sausage, topped with marinara, melted mozzarella & Asiago cheese

Asiago Peppers.

Truffle Fries

$14.42

Shoestring fries tossed with Romano cheese & truffle oil

Truffle Fries.

Pierogies

$14.42

Onions, sour cream, & scallions over six, three cheese pierogies

Pierogies.

Caprese Salad

$15.45

Fresh sliced Yarnick’s tomatoes & sliced buffalo mozzarella topped with fresh basil & drizzled with olive oil & balsamic glaze

Caprese Salad.

Roasted Red Pepper Bisque Or Soup The Day

$5.15+

Red Pepper Tomato Bisque (Bowl)

$7.21

Red Pepper Tomato Bisque (Cup)

$5.15

Soup Of The Day (Bowl)

$7.21

Soup of the Day (Cup)

$5.15

Salads

Pittsburgh Salad-Chicken

$17.51

Blackened chicken mixed with greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, & onions served in a tortilla bowl & topped with shoestring fries & mozzarella

Pittsburgh Salad-Chicken.

Pittsburgh Salad-Steak

$23.69

5oz Steak, mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, & onions served in a tortilla bowl & topped with shoestring fries & mozzarella

Pittsburgh Salad-Steak.

BBQ Chicken Salad

$16.48

Mixed greens, tomatoes, onions, black beans, gouda cheese, chicken & BBQ sauce

BBQ Chicken Salad.

Buffalo Chicken Salad

$16.48

Mixed greens topped with tomatoes, onions, cucumbers, shoestring fries, cheddar jack cheese & choice of grilled or fried chicken tossed in buffalo sauce, suggested dressing - ranch

Buffalo Chicken Salad.

Power Protein Salad

$12.36

Mixed greens, farro grains, pickled onions, sweet potato, tomatoes & avocado lemon aioli paired with salmon if added to salad.

Power Protein Salad.

Summer Berry Salad

$12.36

Mixed greens topped with roasted pecans, strawberries, blueberries & goat cheese

Summer Berry Salad.

Ben's Classic Salad

$10.30

Mixed greens, cucumbers, tomatoes, carrots & onions

Ben's Classic Salad.

Greek Salad

$17.51

Tarragon grilled chicken, mixed greens, olives, feta, tomatoes, cucumbers, onions. Suggested dressing: feta vinaigrette

Greek Salad.

Salad

$3.28

Pizzas

BBQ Chicken Pizza

$18.54

Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onion, gouda & mozzarella cheese

Buffalo Chicken Pizza

$18.54

Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, red onion, cheddar jack & mozzarella cheese

Margherita Pizza

$17.51

Garlic & oil brushed crust topped with fresh basil, tomatoes & mozzarella cheese

Portabello Pizza

$17.51

Garlic & oil brushed crust topped with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, spinach, portobellos, feta & mozzarella cheese

Traditional Pizza

$16.48

Traditional marinara topped with mozzarella cheese

Grilled Flatbreads

BBQ Chicken Flatbread

$16.48

Grilled chicken, BBQ sauce, red onion, gouda & mozzarella cheese

Buffalo Chicken Flatbread

$16.48

Grilled chicken, buffalo sauce, red onion, cheddar jack & mozzarella cheese

Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust

$3.09

Margarita Flatbread

$15.45

Garlic & oil brushed crust topped with fresh basil, tomatoes & mozzarella cheese

Portabello Flatbread

$16.48

Garlic & oil brushed crust topped with tomatoes, green peppers, onions, spinach, portobellos, feta & mozzarella cheese

Traditional Flatbread

$14.42

Traditional marinara topped with mozzarella cheese

Hand Helds/Wraps/Paninis

11:30 AM - 1:30 PM

1/2 Sandwich and Soup

$14.82

Toasted Italian or rye (no sides) turkey: provolone, lettuce, tomato, garlic aioli chicken salad: dried cranberries & apples

1/2 Sandwich and Soup.

Blackened Chicken Wrap

$16.48

Lettuce, tomatoes, chipotle ranch & mozzarella

Blackened Chicken Wrap.

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich

$17.51

Breaded chicken, marinara & mozzarella on a toasted brioche bun

Chicken Parmesan Sandwich.

Whale of Fish Sandwich

$21.63

Oversized fried piece of cod on a hoagie roll with coleslaw & shoestring fries

Whale of Fish Sandwich.

Mushroom Goat Cheese Panini

$16.48

Sautéed mushrooms & onions, spinach, roasted red peppers, goat cheese, balsamic glaze on toasted Italian

Mushroom Goat Cheese Panini.

Chicken Salad Croissant

$16.48

Chicken salad, apples, dried cranberries, topped over lettuce & Swiss cheese

Chicken Salad Croissant.

Rachel

$16.48

Turkey, Swiss, coleslaw & 1000 island on toasted rye

Rachel.

Greek Chicken Wrap

$16.48

Grilled tarragon chicken, mixed greens, feta cucumbers, onions, tomatoes, & feta vinaigrette

Greek Chicken Wrap.

3 Cheese Grilled Cheese and Soup

$15.45

American, Swiss & provolone on Italian with a cup of our tomato bisque (no sides)

3 Cheese Grilled Cheese and Soup.

Vegetable Wrap

$14.42

Sautéed mushrooms, onions, roasted red peppers with lettuce, mozzarella & balsamic glaze

Vegetable Wrap.

Asiago Chicken Sandwich

$16.48

Blackened chicken, grilled banana peppers, asiago cheese, lettuce, tomatoes, & chipotle ranch all served on a brioche bun

Asiago Chicken Sandwich.

Pesto BLT

$15.45

Bacon, lettuce, tomato, basil aioli on choice of Italian or rye

Pesto BLT.

Turkey Brie Melt

$16.48

Turkey, melted brie, and melba sauce on toasted Italian

Turkey Brie Melt.

Burgers

Classic Burger

$15.99

6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Classic Burger.

Bacon Cheddar Burger

$17.51

6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Bacon Cheddar Burger.

Asiago Banana Pepper Burger

$19.57

6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Asiago Banana Pepper Burger.

Mushroom Swiss Burger

$17.51

6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Mushroom Swiss Burger.

Black N Bleu Burger

$17.51

6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Black N Bleu Burger.

Beyond Burger

$18.54

Plant-based vegan burger. 6 oz beef on a brioche bun with lettuce, tomato & pickles on the side, served with shoestring fries

Beyond Burger.

Tacos

Cajun Shrimp Tacos

$14.42

Creamy cilantro lime slaw

Chipotle Chicken Tacos

$14.42

Creamy cilantro lime slaw & green onion

Blackened Chicken Tacos

$14.42

Lettuce, tomato, and mozzarella

Fish Tacos

$14.42

Tomato lime slaw

Mac N' Cheese

Classic Mac N' Cheese

$13.39

Gouda, Asiago & Cheddar Jack

Buffalo Chicken Mac N' Cheese

$16.48

Chicken, buffalo sauce, asiago & cheddar jack

Chicken Gouda Broccoli Mac N' Cheese

$17.51

Chicken, broccoli, gouda, asiago & cheddar jack

Caprese Mac N' Cheese

$15.45

Asiago, Romano, & mozzarella sauce tossed with fresh tomatoes & basil finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle

Caprese Mac N' Cheese.

Mac N Cheese Feature

$16.48

Pastas

4:30 PM - 8 PM

Bangin' Shrimp Pasta

$26.78

Sauteed shrimp, roasted red peppers & linguine simmered in a creamy bangin' alfredo sauce

Build your own Pasta

$15.45

Cheese Tortellini

$23.69

Cheese tortellini, mushrooms, & roasted red peppers simmered in a tomato alfredo sauce

Bruschetta Linguini

$19.57

Linguine tossed in an olive oil & garlic sauce with fresh diced Yarnick's tomatoes & basil, drizzled in balsamic glaze & topped with Asiago

Beef

4:30 PM - 8 PM

12 oz NY Strip

$40.17

12 oz NY Strip.

Filet Boursin

$47.38

6oz of choice aged tenderloin topped with Boursin cheese & a Merlot sauce

Filet Boursin.

Grilled Filet

$46.68

Grilled Filet.

Chicken

4:30 PM - 8 PM

Chicken Marsala

$24.72+

Chicken with mushrooms, shallots, 8 basil simmered in a Marsala demi sauce

Chicken Marsala.

Chicken Parmesan

$24.72+

chicken seasoned in bread crumbs, baked with marinara & mozzarella

Chicken Parmesan.

Chicken Romano

$24.72+

Chicken with seasoned bread crumbs, topped with a Romano cream sauce

Chicken Romano.

Josh's Spicy Chicken

$26.78+

Chicken, crab, & red peppers over penne in a spicy alfredo sauce

Josh's Spicy Chicken.

Chicken Caprese

$24.72+

Chicken baked with buffalo mozzarella, topped with fresh diced tomatoes, garlic, basil & finished with a balsamic glaze drizzle

Chicken Caprese.

Seafood

Mon, Wed-Sun 4:30 PM - 8 PMTue 4:30 PM - 8 AM

Fish Platter

$22.66

Jumbo cod golden fried in beer batter served with fries or potato & vegetables

Fish Platter.

Herb Crusted Cod

$29.87

Cod baked with seasoned breadcrumbs & topped with a light lemon cream sauce

Herb Crusted Cod.

Maple Whiskey Salmon

$29.87

Salmon baked with a sweet and spicy rub, served with pecans, asparagus, & drizzled in a maple whiskey glaze (GF upon request)

Lemon Pesto Salmon

$29.87

Salmon baked in a lemon garlic marinade, topped with baked lemon slices and a fresh basil pesto

Lemon Pesto Salmon.

Firecracker Salmon

$29.87

Salmon baked with a sweet & spicy chili glaze, & topped with fresh green onions

Indiana

Menu

Catering

Jammin Outdoor Dining & Bar

Our Story

We're Hiring

Contact Us

Terms of serviceAccessibility

Indiana Subs n Suds Inc 2026 All Rights Reserved

Powered by Owner